An abandoned church in Newington, Gloucestershire. Photograph: Adrian Sherratt/Alamy Source: Guardian |
Blog notes
'Anonymous' comments for publication must include a pseudonym.
They should be on topic and not involve third parties.
If pseudonyms are linked to commercial sites comments will be removed as spam.
Saturday 26 October 2024
Church closures
Tuesday 15 October 2024
Scottish Episcopal Church drops bullying tribunal against Scotland's first female bishop
Bishop Dyer was suspended in August 2022. Source: STV News |
Thursday 10 October 2024
Black hole
Source: X (formerly Twitter) |
Yesterday, Age UK’s own Equality Impact Assessment was released. It presents the true harm of the Winter Fuel Payment cut. 82% of pensioners in poverty or just above the poverty line will lose up to £300 in energy support this winter.
1, The Prime Minister describing the plight of pensioners when in Opposition.
2. Financial Times report: "UK Treasury refuses to disclose key details of £22bn fiscal ‘black hole’.
Wednesday 2 October 2024
EFCW statement in response to the recent statement by the Bishop of St Asaph at Governing Body
The bishop of St Asaph addressing Governing Body Source: CT/CinW |
Statement from the Evangelical Fellowship in the Church in Wales:
At the recent Governing Body meeting the Bishop of St Asaph made reference to EFCW and previous communications with the Bench of Bishop’s in his answer to a question on Conversion Therapy. His answer can be found here or in the Church Times here. Our response is printed below.
The original 2021 letter to the Bench of Bishops (with their original statement appended) and subsequent correspondence which were referenced are linked underneath.
We regret the interpretation put upon the EFCW letter of June 2021 to the Bench of Bishops in the Bishop of St Asaph’s response to Question 1 at the recent September meeting of the Church in Wales Governing Body. This letter was written to the Bench in good faith, as part of an ongoing dialogue, and we are saddened that reference was made to it in a situation that did not allow a right of reply or clarification before the Governing Body, and in its subsequent publication and distribution. We wish to rebut the implication that EFCW (wittingly or unwittingly) endorses conversion therapy.
EFCW does not, and never has, promoted coercive or abusive practices. Nor do we promote or encourage “practices in which pressure is brought upon vulnerable LGBTQIA persons to submit to efforts aimed at the conversion of their sexuality including attempted exorcisms and worse”, which we also agree are abhorrent.
As evangelical Anglicans we uphold the authority of Scripture over every aspect of our lives, as detailed in Articles 6, 7, 19 and 20. We are concerned that reducing the role of the Church to one simply of “welcome, acceptance and friendship” as the Bishop of St Asaph indicates, without the freedom to discuss the whole Canon of Scripture, or its application to daily life, would undermine the holistic pastoral care and discipleship journeys of those in our congregations.
We would also wish to have protections allowing prayer to take place with people, at their request, in the way the Bishop of St. Asaph suggests, namely “that God’s grace can be operative in the situation, and that a person would know God’s guidance and blessing, without a defined outcome”.
Full details here.
GB question and Bishop Gregory's answer in 'Highlights' (Session Two).
Tuesday 24 September 2024
The Great Church in Wales Giveaway
Original source: X (formerly Twitter) |
The Church in Wales has announced that it is to invest almost £10m in four projects designed to promote growth in church attendance in Wales.
The Church explained that "The grants are being made from the Church Growth Fund, in which the Church is investing £100m to support projects in a once-in-a generation opportunity to resource confident and consistent evangelism throughout Wales."
The diocese of Monmouth is dedicating £1 million to 'help grow new worshipping communities' by targeting local schools.
This news has not been universaly welcomed.
The South Wales Argus described it as a 'Cynical move' to use schools to ease 'plummeting' church membership.
Their community content editor writes:
"Campaigners have urged local authorities to ensure schools 'will not be used as mission fields', after the Church in Wales announced plans to 'build stronger links' with schools in South Wales.
"The diocese plans to install a 'Schools Engagement Pioneer' in areas including North Monmouthshire, Islwyn and Abergavenny to focus on 'relationship-building with primary and secondary school-age pupils in a manner which goes beyond school assemblies'."
A spokesperson for he Diocese of Monmouth explained that it has secured funding of more than £1m to help grow new worshipping communities by building stronger relationships with schools.
What is a Church in Wales 'worshipping community' today and what sort of relationships?
Recently a pride service was held at Newport Cathedral. Their same sex partnered bishop preached. The Celebrant was transgender.
For building 'inclusive' relationships in the Church in Wales see this entry published six years ago. The then preacher now occupies an influential post at Newport Cathedral while the concelebrant has been appointed bishop of Bardsey.
For the love of Christ?
Friday 20 September 2024
Wednesday 11 September 2024
Conned
The Labour winter 2024 - 2025. Source: X (Twitter) |
Sir Keir Starmer's Labour Government secured a majority of 120 in the winter fuel allowance vote to cut the payment for all but the country’s poorest pensioners. A few Labour MPs rebelled with a Labour Government, yes, a Labour government, to paraphrase Neil Kinnock's 1985 conference speech, winning by 348 to 228.
Source: X (Twitter) |
Friday 6 September 2024
Governing Body Highlight
Saturday 31 August 2024
Church in Wales attendance statistics
The Archbishop of Wales addressing Governing Body, September 2023 Source: Church Times/Church in Wales |
'Declining attendance' puts it mildly. British Religion in Numbers (BRIN) showed that the average Sunday attendance (over 18) in 2004 was 41,771. By 2009 attendance had dropped to 36,836.
Ten years on, CinW adult Sunday attendance (over 18) was given in their Membership and Finance Report as 30,424 in 2014. A year later it was 29,019. [See Sept 2016 entry.]
I have been unable to find any reference to current attendance figures for some time which suggests that the Church in Wales has something to hide.
Access to the 'membership app' referred to in the RB Report is by invitation, thus obscuring the data from inquisitive eyes. I wonder why?
Saturday 24 August 2024
Lay Presidency
Saturday 17 August 2024
Wednesday 14 August 2024
Truth and justice?
Rev Dr Bernard Randall Source: Christian Today (Photo: Christian Legal Centre) |
Tuesday 6 August 2024
Fresh start
First Minister of Wales Eluned Morgan Source: Pembrokeshire Herald |
Saturday 27 July 2024
Why?
Paris Olympic Games 2024 opening ceremony Source: X (Twitter) |
The above image is taken from one of a number of Twitter entries showing a parody of The Last Supper in the opening ceremony of the 2024 Olympic games in Paris.
Friday 12 July 2024
Church of England follows Wales into the wilderness
The Bishop of St Asaph, the Rt Revd Gregory Cameron blesses the Revd Lee Taylor and his civil partner, Fabiano da Silva Duarte. Source: Church Times |
Commented at the time: "On Monday 6 September, the Church in Wales voted to allow its clergy to bless same-sex ‘marriages’ and civil partnerships. This was not entirely unexpected given the decline of Christian doctrine and ethics within the Church in Wales in recent years." - The Church in Wales abandons the Christian faith.
It has also abandoned those Anglicans who strive to keep the Christian faith.
Wednesday 3 July 2024
Discrimination and violence against women
An ideology that permits the behaviour described above has no place in civilised society yet its adherents are courted by politicians to gain their support. Even supposedly Christian leaders fall into the same trap.
The goal of Islam is to take over the entire world because they believe that Muslims have a right given by their God, Allah, to "take over the lands of the inferior non-Muslim nations where infidels do not believe in Islam and refuse to worship Allah."
The fate of the West in Muslim eyes has already been made clear.
How can anyone who enjoys their freedom vote for supporters of such an ideology?
Postscript 08.07.2024
The Islamist threat to the West explained by a Palestinian ex-militant.
Wednesday 26 June 2024
Faith 5%
The six Church in Wales diocesan bishops with the newly appointed 'youngest ever bishop' (left) Source: Church in Wales |
"Some people say 'the Church is always after your money' and that money shouldn’t be discussed in church. We believe that with over 2,350 verses in the Bible relating to money and possessions, the subject cannot be ignored. Indeed, the Church in Wales recommends that its members should give 5% of their take-home pay to the Church. We believe that the way we deal with our money speaks volumes about our discipleship. Giving money is part of giving the whole of yourself to God."
In many churches money is necessarily discussed regularly as they try to make ends meet while struggling to pay their diocesan 'share'.
Using some rounded numbers, in Wales 5% of average monthly take home pay of £2,000 amounts to £100 (around £25 per week) which is earmarked for the Church before more deserving causes.
One may ask, What could be more deserving than the Church? There are many deserving causes. The poor. The hungry. The dispossessed. Many relying on charity. The list is endless.
Instead of being a place for worship the Church has become increasingly politicised providing a platform for secular causes, a situation many resent supporting with predictable consequences.
The Church in Wales has long since ceased to be an example of good stewardship, maintaining a bloated structure reminiscent its former thriving self.
In 2012 the Harris Review recommended structural changes including reducing to three administrative centres (Recommendation XXII) followed by Recommendation XXV: "The recommendations XXII, XXIII and XXIV should be reviewed after three years and a judgement made about whether the Church in Wales is best served by six dioceses with three administrative centres or whether it would be more effective to reduce to three dioceses, together with four area bishops."
Instead the bench of bishops have extend their empire, adding assistant bishops, advisors and administrative staff while turning the Church into a home for factional groups seeking to 'legitimise' their secular activities at the expense of the faithful.
The Church in Wales says, "We believe that the way we deal with our money speaks volumes about our discipleship." - Exactly!
With dwindling membership a once thriving Church has become largely irrelevant to former worshipers.
Fortunately the good shepherd knows His sheep and His sheep know Him.
Friday 21 June 2024
Ordinariate Episcopal Ordination
Father David Waller, second Ordinary of the Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham. Source: Catholic News World |
I have heard little of the Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham of late but tomorrow (22nd June) marks a special occasion for the Ordinariate with the Episcopal Ordination of the Revd David Arthur Waller as the second Ordinary, and first Bishop Ordinary, following the retirement of Monsignor Keith Newton.
From their web site:
EPISCOPAL ORDINATION OF BISHOP-ELECT DAVID WALLER - Live Streaming Links
Friday 21st June at 6.00pm
Solemn Evensong and Benediction together with blessing of episcopal insignia at Our Lady of the Assumption Warwick Street.
Livesteam link - www.ordinariate.live
Saturday 22nd June at 11am
The Episcopal Ordination of Bishop Elect David Waller at Westminster Cathedral
The principal consecrator will be His Eminence Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, Prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith.
Livesteam link - Westminster Cathedral YouTube channel
Sunday 23rd June at 10.30am
Solemn Mass at Our Lady of the Assumption Warwick Street,
when Bishop David will take possession of the Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham.
Livesteam link - www.ordinariate.live
We pray for Bishop-elect David as he takes on his new responsibility and give thanks for the ministry of Monsignor Keith Newton as the Ordinariate's first Ordinary.
Wednesday 19 June 2024
Keir Starmer on Islamophobia
In the above video Keir Starmer speaks to Sadiq Khan about how Khan celebrates Eid before going on to discuss Islamophobia which he describes as 'intolerable'.
A phobia is a "persistent, irrational, intense fear of a specific object, activity, or situation (the phobic stimulus), fear that is recognized as being excessive or unreasonable by the individual himself."
There is nothing irrational, excessive or unreasonable about the fear of Islam, a political ideology that sees non-Muslims as infidels. Three things you should know about Islam can be viewed here.
Douglas Murray is one of the few prepared to put the problem of fact and fiction into perspective as he does here.
Islamophobia (as explained here) is an invention designed to grant special privileges that Islam would deny to others.
Witness the fate of Iraqi Christians in 2014 when Islamists gained control there. It is happening to Christian Armenians in Azerbaijan.
The Christian Middle East is now predominantly Muslim, the fate of Great Britain if some Muslims have their way.
In April The Express reported that a "new survey found that nearly half - 46 percent - of British Muslims sympathise with Hamas while a third wished for Shariah law to be implemented in the UK."
Sadiq Khan says it is a priority for him to "build thousands more homes in London for Muslims to live near mosques and halal food shops."
"If Islam ran the country, it would be the end of all our freedoms" warns an ex-Muslim lady.
Starmer's vote gathering is truly offensive in a Christian nation.
Postscript (28.06.2014)
Post by Rafe Heydel-Mankoo, including a prophetic Christopher Hitchins video on X here
Thursday 13 June 2024
Archbishop attracts further criticism
The Archbishop of Wales (right) and gay pride supporters, the sub-dean of Bangor and former Mayor Source: Twitter |
Martin Shipton writes in Nation Cymru:
"Questions are being raised about the judgement of Archbishop of Wales Andy John after the emergence of concerns relating to potential financial irregularities in his home diocese of Bangor.
"Several Church in Wales sources have independently contacted NationCymru to criticise the Archbishop for creating a situation where one cleric – the Rev Canon Siôn ap Rhys-Evans – was effectively running both the diocese of Bangor and its cathedral. He has been on gardening leave since February 29."
Continuing their mushroom method of management the church remains silent about the absence of the sub-dean of Bangor.
Shipton continues, "One Church in Wales source told us: 'The Church is doing its best to keep a lid on this and make sure it doesn’t become a public controversy. But the fact is that the Archbishop made a serious mistake when he appointed Sion Rhys-Evans as the Sub-Dean of Bangor Cathedral in 2021. The fact that he’s in charge of both the cathedral and the diocese is a major problem and he may live to regret it'."
The archbishop's judgement has already been called into question for ignoring the teaching of the Church having remarried after his divorce form his first wife. Also for appointing an assistant bishop who is engaged to another man implying future marriage which contrary to the teaching of the Church in Wales.
Not the symbol of unity his flock expects.
Wednesday 5 June 2024
D-Day: 80th Anniversary Thanksgiving and Apology
D-Day on 6 June 1944 was the largest amphibious invasion in history and was vital in the defeat of the Nazis in the Second World War. Source: Forces Net |
The Commonwealth War Graves Commission web site gives the number of D-Day allied casualties as 156,000. Allied deaths totalled over 4,000 during Operation Overlord.
On the 80th anniversary of the D-Day landings we remember with gratitude all those who perished in conflict and grieve for families who lost loved ones defending our Island only to see their hard won freedom surrendered to an alien ideology. Examples here and here.
Churchill was right.
His resolve:
"We shall defend our Island, whatever the cost may be, we shall fight on the beaches, we shall fight on the landing grounds, we shall fight in the fields and in the streets, we shall fight in the hills; we shall never surrender, and even if, which I do not for a moment believe, this Island or a large part of it were subjugated and starving, then our Empire beyond the seas, armed and guarded by the British Fleet, would carry on the struggle, until, in God’s good time, the New World, with all its power and might, steps forth to the rescue and the liberation of the old."
-Winston Churchill, House of Commons 4 June 1940.
His warning:
"How dreadful are the curses which Mohammedanism lays on its votaries! Besides the fanatical frenzy, which is as dangerous in a man as hydrophobia in a dog, there is this fearful fatalistic apathy. The effects are apparent in many countries, improvident habits, slovenly systems of agriculture, sluggish methods of commerce, and insecurity of property exist wherever the followers of the Prophet rule or live. A degraded sensualism deprives this life of its grace and refinement, the next of its dignity and sanctity. The fact that in Mohammedan law every woman must belong to some man as his absolute property, either as a child, a wife, or a concubine, must delay the final extinction of slavery until the faith of Islam has ceased to be a great power among men. Individual Muslims may show splendid qualities, but the influence of the religion paralyses the social development of those who follow it. No stronger retrograde force exists in the world. Far from being moribund, Mohammedanism is a militant and proselytizing faith. It has already spread throughout Central Africa, raising fearless warriors at every step; and were it not that Christianity is sheltered in the strong arms of science, the science against which it had vainly struggled, the civilization of modern Europe might fall, as fell the civilization of ancient Rome."
- From Churchill Gets the Last Word on Islam (Middle East Forum)
His warning must not go unheeded.
Postscript 13.06.2024
Darren Grimes on the madness of the West’s new religious double standards
https://x.com/darrengrimes_/status/1800868307148718315
Monday 3 June 2024
I don't believe it!
Former Dean of Llandaff, Rev Gerwyn Capon Source: CinW |
From the Diocese of St Asaph:
The Bishop of St Asaph has announced the appointment of a new Archdeacon of Montgomery.
The Revd Gerwyn Capon will take up the post following the retirement of the current Archdeacon, the Venerable Dr Barry Wilson, in August.
Sunday 2 June 2024
Scottish Episcopal Church bishop Anne Dyer to face a disciplinary tribunal
Bishop Dyer has a month to enter her plea ahead of the hearing in Edinburgh in September. Source: Mail Online |
From Mail Online: "Scotland's first female bishop has been accused of bullying but claims she's actually a victim of sexism. As the Right Reverend Anne Dyer faces a church court... just what is the 'conduct unbecoming of the clergy' that could see her axed?" Full report here.
In a previous entry (2018) I commented on a statement by the new Episcopalian Bishop of Aberdeen and Orkney in which she made it clear she was not interested in restricting herself to "prayers, pews and parochial parish life". She would be focused on "fighting for social justice, sexual equality".
Clearly she would have been better employed as a social worker than pretending to be a man of God.
Postscript (14.06.2024)
From BBC News: "Members of the Scottish Episcopal Church who raised concerns about the behaviour of Scotland's first female bishop are urging its senior leader to address what they have described are "baseless accusations" of homophobia and misogyny." Details here.
From Wikipedia: "In February 2021, Dyer was accused of bullying by a number of clergy, laypeople and church employees in The Times.[15] In March 2021, the College of Bishops commissioned Iain Torrance to lead an Independent Review into "difficulties" in the Diocese following a series of allegations regarding the Bishop.[16] In August 2021 the College of Bishops announced their intention to defer publication of the report and move to a second stage of reviewing." Details here.
Friday 24 May 2024
Election farce
Standing in the rain outside 10 Downing Street on Wednesday, the Prime Minister announced that there would be a General Election on 4 July, 2024.
Inclement weather was not the only thing Rishi Sunak was forced to deal with. He had to battle against a loud speaker which almost drowned him out as protesters played 'Things Can Only Get Better'!
Protesters now do as they please, disrupting the free movement of traffic, defacing works of art and public monuments, all under the guise of free speech.
Those of us who are sick and tired of protesters who abuse our freedoms to beat us over the head with will have ample opportunity to demand to know from candidates what they and their Parties propose to do to defend true British values against such abuse.
Monday 13 May 2024
"Church in Wales takes next step towards allowing same-sex marriages"
Llandaff Cathedral Source: Church in Wales |
"The Church in Wales is taking a further step towards changing its rules so same-sex weddings can take place in its churches. Since 2021 it’s been possible for gay couples who have exchanged wedding vows in a civil ceremony to have their new status blessed in a church service. But so far the necessary constitutional move has not been made to permit weddings themselves.
"According to the Church in Wales’ own rules, all three of its sections – clergy, bishops and lay members – must approve such a change, each by a two-thirds majority. But while senior figures are confident that the clergy and bishops would approve the change, they have not been sure of the lay section, a significant number of whom maintain the conservative view that marriage can only be between a man and a woman."
As previously reported, Llandaff Cathedral is to hold a national memorial service for "people who have suffered exclusion from Christian communities because of their sexuality or gender". It is organised by OneBodyOneFaith, the UK’s oldest Christian LGBT+ members’ network, in partnership with The Gathering, an LGBT+ church in Cardiff, and supported by Church in Wales bishops.
The advancement of LGBTQ+ issues now appears to be the main focus of the Church in Wales as they continue to exclude those who keep the faith.
Current Church in Wales rules provide for same-sex blessings following a Civil Ceremony of Marriage or Partnership in a five year experimental rite which expires on 30 September 2026.
The Archbishop of Wales, Andrew John, has expressed his hope that same-sex weddings will then be held in churches in Wales.
To that end the consecration of 'the youngest person ever to become a bishop in the Church in Wales' may have more to do with the fact that the new assistant bishop of Bangor is engaged to a man in a same-sex partnership.
Postscripts
17.05.2024
Church Times (£): Bishop of Lancaster: I cannot judge Welsh bishop
"Provincial autonomy trumps personal convictions about sexuality for Dr Duff at the consecration of the new Assistant Bishop of Bangor."
18.05.2024
Anglican Ink: The start of an episcopal free for all?
Saturday 4 May 2024
Persecution
The above video highlights the persecution of Christians in India.
The Church Times reports how Peers were told of attacks and discrimination suffered by Christians and other religious minorities in Pakistan.
The Bishop of Leicester, the Rt Revd Martyn Snow, said that fewer than 2% of the population of Pakistan were Christian but Christians accounted for more than 80 % of the sewerage and street-cleaning workforce, "where hazardous conditions and a lack of workplace health and safety regulations and protective equipment cause untold preventable accidents, illnesses, and deaths. The accounts of their working conditions are truly repugnant, made even more shocking by the fact that the government agencies advertise cleaning positions for Christians and other religious minorities only."
Lord Alton who introduced the topic said that 3.72 % of the 230 million people in Pakistan were from religious-minority backgrounds. He referred to evidence, found by the APPG for Pakistani Minorities, of "discrimination and persecution against minorities, entrenched in school textbooks; stigmatisation in schools and colleges; and primitive and dismal conditions in the so-called colonies where Christians live, which are often devoid of running water, sanitation and electricity."
According to the Christian Non Government Organisation Open Doors "one in seven Christians worldwide face persecution and discrimination for their faith."
Meanwhile, Letters to the Editor in the Church Times contain a response to the continuing persecution of fellow Anglicans in their own Church by Women And The Church (WATCH) who, devoid of any integrity, think it their Church alone.
Saturday 27 April 2024
Pollution
Archbishop of Wales, Andrew John addressing Governing Body Source: CinW |
Tuesday 16 April 2024
WATCH, true colours
The Rt Revd Philip North, Bishop of Blackburn Source: Geoff Crawford/Church Times |
A Review of the appointment of the Rt Revd Philip North as Bishop of Blackburn has concluded that his nomination followed the proper processes, but makes several recommendations how these processes could be improved.
The Church Times reports that
"Campaigners had raised concerns about Bishop North’s views on the ordination of women, which he has said is an area on which the Church of England should not be at variance with the wider Church (News, 15 September 2017).
"A submission by the campaign group Women and the Church (WATCH) centred on concerns about how having a bishop who does not ordain women could undermine clergy in the diocese and the diocesan bishop’s function as a figure of unity..."
Forward in Faith commented:
"The Independent Reviewer has rightly restated that, following a submission to her from Women and the Church (WATCH) regarding the appointment of diocesan bishops in the Church of England and in line with the Church’s Five Guiding Principles, being a traditionalist is not a bar to becoming a diocesan bishop.
"However, Forward in Faith also notes with concern that the Independent Reviewer has recommended in her report that consideration be given to re-examining the scope of her role. It is not clear to Forward in Faith from the contents of the report exactly what deficiency in the current arrangements would be met by such a change.
"As WATCH has demonstrated in its referral on the appointment of diocesan bishops, any individual or interested party can make a referral to the Independent Reviewer. The Independent Reviewer can then assess the points made in those referrals.
"The critical question must always be how those referrals relate to the 2014 House of Bishops’ Declaration on the Ministry of Bishops and Priests. If there has been any breach of that Declaration, from whatever part of the Church it might have come, then it needs to be addressed directly and transparently. However, simply not agreeing with, or feeling uncomfortable with, the contents of the Declaration can never be, and should never be, grounds for a referral to the Independent Reviewer.
"The direction of travel being opened up by the Independent Reviewer runs the risk of undermining the Declaration, which quite rightly seeks to promote the flourishing of all parts of the Church and to uphold and protect the minority position in the Church of England, which in part occurs through the work of the Independent Reviewer.
"Forward in Faith remains strongly of the view that the Church of England benefits from the breadth of its witness, including the catholic teaching and practice which it holds in common with the universal Church."
Once again WATCH show themselves in their true colours as a group of feminists using the Church to further their feminist cause regardless of the effect on others.
Tuesday 9 April 2024
Christians surrendering to Islam
The Islamic Grand Iftar celebrated recently at Bristol Cathedral Source: X (formerly Twitter) |
The organisers of the Islamic Grand Iftar in Bristol Cathedral last week claimed it shows unity.
The reality is different as witnessed here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here and here among many other references to be found on X (formerly Twitter) and news outlets.
There is no reciprocity. No concessions to those Islam regards as infidels and dhimmis yet Muslims are allowed to pray in Christian churches which are then regarded by them as mosques in which to pray that there is no god but Allah.
What hope is there for Christianity in this country when the Churches surrender to Islam in this absurd one-way traffic!
Postscript [10.04.2024]
Adhan (Call to Prayer) in Buckingham Palace. What next?