You are here . on the pale blue dot


Blog notes

'Anonymous' comments for publication must include a pseudonym.

They should be on topic and not involve third parties.
If pseudonyms are linked to commercial sites comments will be removed as spam.


Saturday 11 March 2023

Some Comparisons

Benito Mussolini and Gary Lineker striking poses

Soccer pundit Gary Lineker dropped himself right in it when he compared the language used to launch the government's new asylum policy with that used in 1930s Germany.

In the same spirit, his balcony pose in a BBC News bulletin reminded me of more graphic analogy from that era.

The BBC said that the sports presenter was taken off their Match of the Day show after a row about the impartiality of Lineker's tweets claiming that he had breached its social media guidelines for tweeting about the government's new migration law.

Not wanting to be left behind, an increasing number of pundits are withdrawing their services in a show of solidarity for Lineker.

I see from his Twitter account that Lineker has 8.8M followers which may account for the outpouring of sympathy for the BBC’s top earner of over £1 million annually. 

By contrast Home Secretary Suella Braverman has a mere 120.9K Twitter followers.

From a Church Times tweet about another BBC casualty: "The BBC Singers is one of the leading advocates of choral music in the world, and their budget probably equals one sport presenter’s salary. The BBC corporate spin on it is beyond belief."

Sympathisers can sign a petition to stop the planned closure of the BBC Singers here.

The BBC previously announced that some of their News channel’s most famous faces, including Jane Hill, Ben Brown and Martine Croxall, were to be axed before the launch of a channel that combines international and domestic news.

For those of us who find the BBC's obsession with soccer completely disproportionate, some trimming of the seemingly endless number or presenters, commentators and reporters is long overdue.

The commentator John Motson  unwittingly summed up the problem in a quote from a tribute following his death. When the BBC apologised for a delay in presenting the News because coverage of a soccer game had overrun, Motson retorted, soccer is the news!

For too many he was right.

20 comments:

  1. To be honest AB, Lineker's observations ref comment, language and tone used by the Home Secretary ref 1939 Germany was probably fair. Contention is whether he should have expressed his views on his Twitter or whatever account. In that, he most certainly did cross the Corporation's line but no worse than scores of leading Westminster politicians of all parties who do similar on range of issues. Some get caught out, some don't. But Lineker's cross-armed pose has no similarity with Mussolini ... he just happens to be crossing his arms. The greater comparison in jaw-out, Alpha-male ranting would be Mussolini and Donald Trump.

    Personally, it doesn't bother me. I was able to watch a wonderful Welsh rugby win over Italy with commentators, pundits, strategists etc. on ITV this afternoon without disruption or any reference whatsoever to the girlie-game of soccer!!

    Ad Clerum

    ReplyDelete
  2. What's going to be more interesting (and depressing) in development of this non-story is how many of our bishops will tonight be burning the midnight oil scripting their pulpit sermons on Saint Lineker and their attacks on the Establishment, the Home Secretary, the BBC etc. and then in weeks to come scratch their heads again wondering why Religious Broadcast programmes have lost their popularity with listeners and tv viewers and more pews empty.
    I can't imagine on what Gospel reading they'll base their pulpit nonsenses, but rest assured they'll find one. Bishops are adept at demonstrating that they're generally out of touch.
    Lead on this subject no doubt will be the plonker +Andrew John who a few years ago drove a charabagne convoy with his Bob-the-Builder pretend Lifeboatman to Sangatte, near Calais banner-waving his support for the hoardes determined to cross over to UK mainly for our social-services, handouts and benefits. He quite ignored the fact that the then Bishop of Dover and others on the Kent/East Anglia coast were begging to the closure of the 'refugee' Jungle campsite as was the Bishop of Pas-des-Calais and their voices, rather than the Bishop of Bangor, won the day. By this time of course, he'd reaped the ££ donations of his gullible parishes and parishioners to throw at a 'lost cause'. His donations of tents and clothes etc. was added to the bonfire by the French Gendarmerie who closed the site on humanatarian grounds. Apology?? From ++Andrew??? How ridiculous to even think of such thing. But bets are he'll 'pontificate' on the Lineker in some form or another and if he doesn't preach it, then use his website to promote it. Goose and gander.

    Old Bill.

    ReplyDelete
  3. No doubt many of us who have relatives who endured persecution in the Third Reich resent the trivilisation of their experience by comparing their flight from Germany to that of present economic migrants. It would also be interested to know what level of scholarship informed the initial comparison.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, I shall say that Gary has a refugee staying with him ( he doesn't shout that from the rooftops), and has supported refugee charities for many years. He made the comments on his PERSONAL twitter account and that's something that the BBC has defended on times when Tory politicians have made distasteful remarks on their PERSONAL accounts. How many refugees have the Welsh Plankers invited into their rather nice houses?

      Delete
    2. Baptist Trainfan12 March 2023 at 17:30

      My father spent a while in Dachau c.1937 for having participated in student politics, and (with my mother) came to Britain in 1938. I do not resent Lineker's comment but welcome it.

      Delete
    3. My wife and her family were Jewish and got out of Germany in Aug 1939. However my father-in-law stayed behind and was murdered, even though he in WWI had been awarded the Iron Cross 1st class, by the einsatzgruppen in a ditch near Kovno in 1941. They were not economic migrants, they were fleeing for their lives.

      Delete
    4. Not illegal economic migrants turning up with the latest smart mobile phones but no passports either!

      Delete
    5. @Merthyr Organist
      https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-64967941
      Is Lineker hosting any of those found claiming falsely to be football players?

      Delete
  4. MOTD reduced to 20 minutes duration.
    99.9% of women in the land will rejoice and there is indeed a God.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The BBC gets it all wrong again in making a big issue out of GL's Twitter comments. GL is insignificant other than on MOTD and his comments carry no weight. They are just as wrong in affording - at our expense - his fee of 1m per annum. Why does the BBC find it necessary to dish out large salaries to nonentities? Former R2 DJ Chris Evans 3m per annum.
    LW

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Agreed on all points.

      Delete
    2. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-64936917
      Shame he wasn't taken off air permanently, saving the licence fee payers £1.4 million at a single stroke.

      Delete
  6. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-64944416
    Interesting new development in the US abortion debate.

    ReplyDelete
  7. GL has made comments outside of his working hours and using personal equipment. Regardless of what he has said, he has not used any equipment or avenue supplied by his "employer"

    ReplyDelete
  8. Another comparison and the funniest news this week.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-64976104
    "SNP says its membership has fallen to 72,000"

    Losing members almost as fast as the Cult in Wales.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-65000606
      If only the "Chief Executive" of Cult in Wales would resign so quickly.

      Delete
  9. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-64984878
    Racist, sexist and homophobic?
    Well I never!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Could this be known as putting one's Foot in it?
    http://digitaleditions.telegraph.co.uk/data/1284/reader/reader.html?social#!preferred/0/package/1284/pub/1284/page/32/article/NaN
    🤣 🤣 🤣
    The role of Dick the Dean doesn't get a dishonourable mention today but the investigation by Dominic Grieve KC continues.

    ReplyDelete
  11. The Met continues to cover itself in glory.
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-65005957
    Officers accused of sexual misconduct working as normal.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Deep and widespread failings in the Met.
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65019879
    The report merely confirms what so many have known and suffered for decades.

    ReplyDelete